March 20, 2011

The Mystery of Dr. Sha

Last fall, John Chitty, a man I know in Boulder, was diagnosed with stage 4 prostate cancer. His PSA score was 266! (Most doctors consider a normal score to be 4 or below) The cancer had metastasized to his bones and lungs with tumors “too numerous to count.” His prognosis, obviously, was dire.

Because John founded and heads the Colorado School of Energy Studies, he launched a full-out campaign to heal himself, doing everything he knew or learned about to make his body inhospitable to cancer. He ate only greens and seeds, had coffee enemas and oxygen treatments and took supplements too numerous to count.

A friend brought him to a talk by Dr. Zhi Gong Sha, who has an MD in western medicine from Xi’an JiaoTong University, was named Qigong Master of the Year in 2002 by the World Congress on Qigong, and is a Grandmaster of Taoist healing. That meeting would dramatically affect the course of John’s illness.

Dr. Sha

John had no symptoms except frequent urination. At the talk, Dr. Sha demonstrated his treatment on John and the next morning, John says, urination was back to normal. Dr. Sha had offered John free tuition at a 10-day workshop, so John dropped everything and left for 10 days of nonstop Taoist practices and more healing from Dr. Sha. Shortly afterward, when John was tested again, his PSA score was…. Want to guess?

John told me: “It’s 1.4.” His oncologist called this “remarkable,” and x-rays of his lungs showed the tumors were all shrinking.

How had this happened? John had been taking hormones that block testosterone and was also doing dozens of natural interventions. (For a list, click here) But he feels Dr. Sha’s healing was a “huge factor” in his improvement.

A few months later, when I was in Hawaii, my sister, Terry, told me Dr. Sha was coming to Honolulu. Terry had recently developed four lumps on her thyroid -- diagnosed as “multi-nodular goiter.” The doctor told her it would not go away through diet or medication and they would watch it for six months, hoping it would not grow larger.

Since Terry needed healing and I was curious to see Dr. Sha, we each paid $100 for his Soul Healing Day at the Ilikai Hotel. I’ve never seen anyone work like Dr. Sha. When he demonstrates on Angelika Carmona, who has just been diagnosed with breast cancer, he makes sharp movements with his arms, stomps his foot and yells so loudly that I jump: “Trans-mission!” He asks everyone in the room to point to Angelika, shake their hands rapidly and chant phrases like, “Divine treasures, heal her!”

Angelika does not wish to receive radiation or chemotherapy. Dr. Sha asks two MD’s who’re attending the workshop, a professor at the University of Hawaii medical school and a retired surgeon, to palpate Angelika’s tumor. They describe it as 4 cm, hard and immovable. For the next four hours, Dr. Sha chants, sings, yells, swings his arms, calls on the divine and urges the group to chant and shake their hands rapidly. He takes off his suit jacket and wipes sweat from his face. Looking around, I feel like I’m at a mass faith healing.

Dr. Sha asserts that the cause of all sickness is karma—the effects of deeds from this life and past ones—and that if he can clear the bad karma, the person will get well because the soul has been healed. He tells us a curse has been placed on Angelika’s breast by someone she harmed in a past life. He sees “dark souls” in Angelika’s body and gives the command for them to leave. “Trans-mission!” Moments later, he says, “Dark souls are gone!” People applaud.

I must acknowledge that I’m an agnostic when it comes to reincarnation, let alone dark souls and curses. I don’t believe, literally, that we go through life again and again in different bodies, although I can entertain the concept as a metaphor. As for karma, something feels intuitively right about “what goes around comes around,” but how that works exactly is, to me, a mystery.

At the Ilikai Hotel, I can’t say if dark souls have been exorcised from Angelika’s body, but the two M.D.’s who examine her report that the tumor has shrunk to 1.5 cm and is soft and pliable. Angelika looks flushed and radiant, smiling with tears in her eyes.

When I describe this later to Donald Abrams, MD, an integrative oncologist who’s chief of oncology at San Francisco General Hospital, he says, “It would be better if they’d done an MRI or other scan before and after Dr. Sha’s treatment to provide objective evidence.” When I tell this to Angelika, she says she had three MRI’s before seeing Dr. Sha but won’t have any more radiation because it’s harmful to the immune system. She’s using Dr. Sha’s healing techniques herself and will have a thermography test on April 19. “I think I can get it out of my system completely by then,” she says.

Dr. Sha tells people at the workshop that after a break, he’ll clear karma, remove curses and heal sicknesses. After he leaves the room, an assistant makes the pitch: $1,000 to clear karma, $500 to remove a curse and $500 to heal an illness. “This is cheap,” the assistant says, explaining that people who have cancer could be charged hundreds of thousands for western medical treatment. He adds, “How can you put a price on clearing karma?” Dr. Sha tells me later that he’s been guided to charge “honor fees” because “people have a spiritual debt they need to honor.” So here’s my question: You can see and feel if a healing produces results, but how can you tell if karma truly has been cleared?

Since I had no illness, I decided to leave then but Terry stayed to have her goiter healed. The next morning, she called and said, “It’s amazing -- the nodules are gone.” She and her husband couldn’t find the largest nodule that they’d had no trouble finding before, although she still felt soreness in her throat. She’s eager to see what her tests will show in six months.

I find Dr. Sha a consummate paradox. He’s extremely generous and he’s constantly selling. He gave my friend John free treatments and tuition, while others paid more than ten thousand for his services. In his books he teaches you to clear your own karma, but if you attend one of his soul healing days, he’ll do it for you and says that works fastest. He speaks about dark souls and curses yet his work is producing results that are palpable. People say he’s healed them of blindness, deafness and tumors, yet others have died. Dr. Sha acknowledges, “Nothing works 100% of the time.”

After spending three days around him, what I can say is that I feel an expansion of love and a resolve to serve more. Returning to the place I’m renting in Kailua, I picked up an old book, “The Golden Bough,” and came across a passage that was uncannily similar to what I witnessed with Dr Sha. It describes a small village in Indonesia where, when sickness ravages the population, they build a boat and everyone fills it with whatever they can offer — rice, tobacco, eggs. They take the boat to the sea, push it off and watch until it disappears from sight. Then the leader cries out: “The sicknesses are now gone, vanished, expelled, and sailed away!” Everyone cheers.

PLEASE LEAVE A COMMENT

SIGN UP to be receive future blogs free.

45 comments:

Sheila said...

Oh vey is all I can say! If only I could really truly believe.

Beauregard said...

Please make sure to follow up in six months and one year. While it's true the power of the human mind and body surpasses our understanding, it's also true that people facing horrible disease often fall prey to medicine men.
"If your mother says she loves you, check it out."
I hope for the best for your loved ones and you.

Peter Lake, LAKE Real Estate said...

My left knee was improved when I took a placebo in a double-blind drug study.

That said, I think this is all horseshit.

Victory's Vision said...

It is amazing how people take their religious prejudice shield off at times. Man is a faith being. Your belief can kill you or heal you. The people in this story never considered it was their belief that put them into the condition in the first place.
I read a book by the late Norman Cousins, The Healing Heart. The forward in the book had a story about a young intern that had a patient with a bad heart valve which made her ankles swell. The head doctor, with all the interns in tow, checked the patient and stated out loud that this woman has T.S., (Tricuspid Stenosis). The woman BELIEVED the head doctor meant TERMINAL SYMPTOMS. After the head doctor left the patient began to go into cardiac arrest. No matter what the young intern told her she would not believe him because he did not have the education or knowledge of the head doctor. The woman died.
The young intern became the head of the cardiology dept. and decided to tell each heart attack patient he saw in the emergency room that they would live. He saw that as half the treatment.

Ilene Marder said...

I live in Woodstock, so I really should take this withOUT a grain of salt! But I'd be more comfortable if we had some real percentages of people healed long-term and those who don't make it.
I agree the mind is the most potent healing force we have, but...hmmmmm, believing this is a challenge.

Anonymous said...

I believe our minds and bodies are miracles, and have to give the Divine credit for this. That said, there are charlatans out there and we must be watchful. There are also miracles.
Cee Howard

Anonymous said...

God doesn't charge anything for healing, just prayer and faith.

Bruce Nygren said...

Somehow, the only problem I'm having is the good doctor's own explanation of what's going on. My experience with powerful beings is that, while powerful,their intellectual understanding of what is occurring is very often lacking, and sometimes self-serving.
Just because he says it's about clearing karma doesn't make it so. The explanation doesn't have to be correct for the treatment to work.

Attila said...

I have seen him. Several friends have seen him. I think he is something of a con artist. He offers something perhaps, but he digs deep into your wallet after wooing you with free events, books, etc.
The Sha treatments for me did nothing whatsoever.
Muscle testing him with Dr Hawkins Map of Consciousness-- it's a powerful negative.

Ruslan said...

Wow! Nothing succeeds like success. So if Dr. Sha's treatments work for your friend and your sister, that's significant. Anyway, in this world of diversity, one person's horseshit is another's compost. As the Indonesians say, "Bagaimana nanti." ("Let's see how things stand later.") Pragmatism rules: Results first, explanations down the road, if ever.

Ren Feldman, Boulder

Sara Davidson said...

Thanks for your incredible comments.
Peter, when placebos work, they show that the body (with or without the mind's involvement)has the capacity to heal itself. That's what Dr. Weil asserts in "Spontaneous Healing." So be happy for placebos.
Bruce, what you said about explanations is startling and true. Because words can't express the ineffable. Which is why I agree with Ren: Results first, explanations later.
AND, I will follow up w. these folks in 6 months and a year.

Margaret Pevec said...

I appreciate your reporting on Dr. Sha, especially listing the paradoxes, and expressing your own skepticism. I have been a student of alternative healing since I encountered Caroline Myss's lectures in 1995 (her first was "Why People Don't Heal and How They Can"). Although I DO believe in reincarnation (it explains so much), but don't really resonate with the idea of karma; and generally am open to hearing about everything and don't feel a need to have firm opinions, I find it refreshing to be given new information without the hype, either for or against it. Dr. Sha is out there. He's doing something. People are paying for it. And maybe I will too, should it come to that. Or maybe I'll just decide not to do anything; to just let go and count this lifetime as sufficient, whenever my body says "enough is enough." I think energy medicine is here to stay and grow. Caroline Myss described herself as a medical intuitive in 1995, and said "in 10 years, this will not sound strange." She was right, at least for people who are following the trend. It's exciting, confusing, and truly makes life interesting to know about people like John of God and Dr. Sha. I hope you'll continue reporting on your sister and your friend's process; and don't dump the skepticism!

Anonymous said...

Joao of God, the Brazilian faith healer...I wonder how this guy is with back pain? Did anyone have that?
BTW, keep in mind that there is NO radiation from an MRI. A CT scan does involve a substantial amount, and an x-ray much less, but some. Sorry to be such a know-it-all.

Slim said...

Dear Sara,I love your writing. Just finished your fascinating essay on Dr. Sha ....Thank you

Ann said...

Hi Sara, what a wonderful story. I have heard of persons like Dr. Sha.

I wish I were home in Honolulu to see him (and you) in person, but I'm in Washington, DC doing Stop the War protests.

michele said...

What do the Muslims say: Trust Allah but tie up your camel? For me, I go within for healing, answers & to set my compass. In dealing w/illness I've sometimes prayed real hard for help & just as often I've trusted doctors when that felt like the correct approach. I don't see karma as necessarily negative but as a chance to grow & change.

Anonymous said...

The human mind is a very powerful thing. I have seen people believe themselves well for a period of time - sometimes a very long time but eventually we all do end. Believe.
Perhaps that is what he is offering. The traditional oncology system is very very terrifying and moves rapidly from one treatment to the next - a bustling hive of activity where the patient and their family are bewildered at what is happening. Perhaps this intense positive experience is a refreshing alternative to what is often presented as an intrusive yet foregone conclusion. As Christopher Hitchens mentions - there is no stage 5. Believe.

Shunya said...

You certainly voiced many of the experiences I had on first meeting Doctor Sha, and even continue to have. I have no doubt that many of these thoughts and feelings are very common.

I wonder often if they have much to do with my very California upbringing, which is very different than that of people I have met who were raised in China. This difference often seems to lead to seeing the world in very different ways.

What I have experienced is that moving past my own discomforts, to find the essence of what Doctor Sha has to share, has accelerated my spiritual journey tremendously. According to my clients, it has made me an exponentially better healer, and as many friends have pointed out to me, has made me a better person.

Blessings,
Shunya
Institute for Soul Healing & Enlightenment
shunya@drsha.com

janatd33 said...

Fellow detectives in the healing mystery: we have clues, that's all! I specialize in working with the psyches of people with physical illness and pain: a former Esalen employee, I'm now a psychotherapist in Boulder with a doctorate and have studied alternative healings, including my own, since 1978. I've worked with lots of folks with M.S. among other illnesses. Here are 3 comments on the cases above:
a. It's a fascinating mystery:
Ultimately all there is, is energy in various forms, so energy healing makes sense. And I've experienced one Phillipino psychic surgery that ended up being a pricey joke, so beware. While there's hard evidence for some energy healings, it's not simple: we know that placebo effect works 1/3 of the time in medicine. Contrary to new age doctrine, it's not simply about belief: infants and animals getting vaccinations or antibiotics have no belief in the treatments. The more open minded and rigorous research we can get on guys like John of God and all the other thousands of significant energy healers, the more we can make sense of when, how, for how long, and why such things work.The International Society for the Study of Subtle Energies and Energy Medicine(ISSSEEM) in Denver has for 20 years been putting more hard science study into energy healings than anyone. Boulder psychologist Carol Schneider is one of the founders.
b. Yes, there's seems to be an odd mix in urban Asian culture today of selflessness and entrepreneurship.
c. Angelika doesn't want any more radiation because it's harmful to the immune system; but MRI's are not radiation, they work by magnets.
Here's to the Mystery!
Charles Horowitz, Ph.D.

Grace said...

Certainly skeptical to this, but on the other hand - who's to say? I read an interesting book called "The Way of the Explorer" by Edgar Mitchell, a former astronaut that may be familiar to some here. He encountered two people who changed his perception of what is possible in the realm of physical healing, and as I read his story - I was having a hard time believing he was just "out there". So whether Dr. Sha genuinely has tapped into healing powers or not, who's to say? I probably fall into the arena of the more skeptical people though....

Anonymous said...

I once heard a spiritual teacher respond to a question about healing by saying that the deepest healing was to realize that there was nobody there to be healed.

Now this may seem like a extreme viewpoint but it begs a really fundamental question of identity, who are we really?

If your answer is spirit or essence, consciousness or awar- ness, does this Consciousness or awareness or essence or whatever you want to call it get sick or dis-eased?

And if so, how so?

My experience with my own body's health and working w/others in the healing field for over twenty years lead me to believe that consciousness can easily get misled and start believing it's something that it's not, like exclusively and primarily a body/mind.
Then this body/mind has karma and past lives that have to be healed and cleared and balanced and aligned and on and on and on.

There's a whole industry out there ready to sell you all of that.

I'm all for taking care of the body and even being curious about things I don't understand but I'm not interested at all about buying into new age belief system (based on ancient healing belief systems) carte blanch. Flat out, it's what I would call superstition.

Thanks Sara for an interesting dialogue on healing

A New Age healing heretic

Anonymous said...

Sarah, I suppose usless one experiences these miraculous healings one remains leary or sceptical. Often times when a person has exhausted the options such as radiation and kemotherapy they surrender to things they have not tried. I respect each decison one makes in reference to his or her beliefs. Why do we cast judgement on ourselves and others so instantaneously. Would it not be an more lovely and loving to respect each others right to make decisions. I have personally experienced very amazing healings. The first by Sai Babba who appeared to me and removed two deliberating injured areas of my body. I also asked to be healed of a childhood trauma and he told me to go to John of God of Brazil. I received an open heart spiritual intervention from John of God at the Omeaga Institute in Reinbeck, NY. I have been hugely impacted by both and never was there a moment throughout it all that I doubted, that is my experience and I don't expect anyone to believe me or do I impose my beliefs on anyone who is sick and requires care. I love and respect each persons decision and allow them to be themselves and don't we all wish that love could be unconditional in nature for all of us. I have said my peace.

val321 said...

I have read Dr. Sha's "Soul Wisdom I" and it was an extremely intense book about the soul and how we need to live and believe in our soul. If you are agnostic this concept would be difficult to understand. I think it would be interesting to meet Dr. Sha. If you are a religious person and are open to other religious thoughts the book is worth reading.

Sharon said...

Like you, Sara, I'm an agnostic. Although I know that much is unavailable to my five senses, I don't readily believe that all who claim access are speaking truth. I am glad to hear of the healings you mention. Hopefully, those healed will have continued good health.

Susan Schwartz said...

Sara,
I take it like this: for all of its
insights,Western medicine has very little understanding of how the body works. And even less what it is/may be capable of. The healing rates on chemo/radiation are not that great, but people follow those treatments because we know that poison kills cancer cells. (Along with everything else.)If Western med was Dr. Sha, we'd say, his results were unreliable. As for selling/ generosity...why shouldn't he be paid for his services? See what it costs to spend 4 hours in the emergency room...let alone overnight in the hospital. I'm not saying I'm ready to turn my back on the Western approach..but I think "alternative" medicine has a lot more going for it than we give it credit for. And saying it's all
voodoo is just another way of saying we don't understand why it works. Duh.

Susan Schwartz said...

Sara,
I take it like this: for all of its
insights, Western medicine has very little understanding of how the body works. And even less what it is/may be capable of. The healing rates on chemo/radiation are not that great, but people follow those treatments because we know that poison kills cancer cells. (Along with everything else.)If Western med was Dr. Sha, we'd say, his results were unreliable. As for selling/ generosity...why shouldn't he be paid for his services? See what it costs to spend 4 hours in the emergency room...let alone overnight in the hospital. I'm not saying I'm ready to turn my back on the Western approach..but I think "alternative" medicine has a lot more going for it than we give it credit for. And saying it's all
voodoo is just another way of saying we don't understand why it works. Duh.

Anonymous said...

Fascinating stuff and can I recommend to anyone author UK Allegra Taylor's 1987 book 'I Fly Out With Bright Feathers' (The Quest of a Novice Healer). Taylor had an interesting natural healing experience and then traveled the world to see how faith healers (USA), psychic surgeons in the Philippines, someone in Australia etc. A great read - Robin Katz

Anonymous said...

as Carol Eastman once said
"life is a karmic penal colony"
paying someone to clear your karma is an ancient tradition for the moneyed, who sometimes do not have time to carry out the practices for clearing karma themselves. The smoke offering practice called Riwo Sangchod comes to mind. Good to do daily, in the am
and it is fun, too

irv thomas said...

First of all, what is so special about skepticism? I mean, people either seem proud of it, or think they're protected by it, or somehow feeling they are better off for it . . . they seem to wear it, here, like a badge of honor.

For my own part, I'd prefer to be free of it. It's just another belief system. Which is the entire problem here: belief systems. One of your commenters notes: "infants and animals getting vaccinations or antibiotics have no belief in the treatments" [ventured to show that belief isn't responsible for healing]. What's not noted, however, is that infants and animals have no dis-belief, either.

The mind's fixations -- including skepticism -- are the essential problem. Being OPEN: open to as much as possible, is the most effective way to live. In just about every sphere.

Anonymous said...

Sounds like hoky poky to me.

mala41 said...

Wow Sarah, you sure have a fascinating blog.
It seems that there is just no way to predict who the responders to treatment will be. Confidence, hope, and leaving no stone unturned do not seem to make a difference. Have you ever read Grace and Grit?

Jackson said...

Very amazing. Thanks Sara. Cheers

Sara Davidson said...

What great and provocative comments!

Mala, yes, I've read Grace and Grit. It's the only one of Ken Wilber's books I've been able to read, because it comes from the heart, not the mind. You're right, sometimes nothing seems to work. All one can say is that it was that person's time to go. Other times, miracles happen. It's all a mystery, isn't it?

Irv, I love what you wrote about skepticism being just another belief system. I heartily concur.

Anonymous said...

I wish I could pass this along to some of my friends but I'm afraid they['ll think I'm crazy to believe this. I say if it works, so what!

Just one error I spotted: MRIs do not emit radiation, that's cat scans that do plus x-rays, of course.

Charles Horowitz, Ph.D. said...

I've studied alternative healings, including my own, since 1978 and I specialize in working with the psyches of people with serious physical illness and pain; I'm a psychotherapist with a doctorate. Here are my comments on the cases above:
a. It's a fascinating mystery:
First, regarding arguments for and against the possibility of such authentic healings, I would say that just because we've no proof or understanding does not mean it is, or isn't, so. We thought the world was flat and still until a few centuries ago. Germ theory was not known until 1850; physicians did not wash their hands! Yet penicillin was used for infections for a few thousand years, i.e. in ancient Greece and China, before we understood it biologically, and it worked. It came in the form of blue bread mold, you will see if you Google it's history. Likewise, these energy healings may or may not work, and we don't yet know why or when.
Ultimately all there is, is energy in various forms, so energy healing makes sense. And I've experienced one Phillipino psychic surgery that ended up being a pricey joke, so beware: charlatans do exist, psychic healers may be real, and it's hard to impossible to discern who is what. While there's hard evidence for some energy healings, it's not simple: we know that placebo effect works 1/3 of the time in medicine. Contrary to new age doctrine, it's not simply about belief: infants and animals getting vaccinations or antibiotics have no belief in the treatments. The more open minded and rigorous research we can get on guys like John of God and all the other thousands of significant energy healers, the more we can make sense of when, how, for how long, and why such things work. The International Society for the Study of Subtle Energies and Energy Medicine(ISSSEEM) in Denver appears to have been putting more hard science study into energy healings than anyone for 20 years. Boulder psychologist Carol Schneider is one of the founders.
Also, if you're interested in pursuing this direction locally, google the Boulder Camera's 12/15/10 article, "Where soul meets body." There are 4 "intuitive healers" profiled there who I met at a meeting regarding setting up a possible conference on "the truth about quantum physics and healing." All I can say from that administrative meeting is that they were kind and sincere.
The bottom line is, what works? If I was told I had an inoperable brain tumor by a number of Western doctors and they said there was nothing to help me, I'd see John of God in Brazil. It'll cost $2K, and it might work! You don't know. I've heard a mix of reports directly from people who've seen him: some healed miraculously, some not.
b. Yes, there's seems to be an odd mix in urban Asian culture today of selflessness and entrepreneurship.
c. Angelika doesn't want any more radiation because it's harmful to the immune system; but MRI's are not radiation, they work by magnets.
Here's to the Mystery and to healing!
Charles Horowitz, Ph.D.

nobody's fool said...

MRIs use magnetic resonance, if I'm not mistaken; they don't give out radiation. So they're "safe" in that respect.

The mind is powerful and it's full of things we don't remember or know how to use. Anything that assists us to unlock what we already know (like how to heal ourselves) is a good thing.

I can understand charging for this service -- everyone's gotta eat -- but exorbitant pricing seems like bad karma in itself.

nobody's fool said...

One more thing, after reading Mr. Chitty's list of things he's taking, I noted the testosterone hormone blocker he's taking is Lupron. For the record, if nothing has changed, Lupron is FDA-approved only for this purpose: shrinkage of the prostate.

However, it has been widely used in WOMEN to shrink fibroids in the uterus, with dubious results.

One result duly noted (and personally experienced) is that Lupron will shut off ALL hormones; not just testosterone. It shuts off ever.single.one of them. It's a horror. Women immediately go into chemical menopause -- hot flashes, night sweats, emotional rollercoaster, dry (you know where), etc. One can only imagine the long-term effects on both women and men using this drug.

Anyway, just a quick PSA for anyone who's approached with using this drug; it's food for thought. Were I given the choice with what I know now, there is no way in hell I would have allowed them to shoot me up with it.

Barbra said...

I have often healed my body with my mind. I believe in the mind's ability to heal the body.
That's how Placebos work, after all.

Shunya said...

Another comment after reading some 30+ comments:

Before there were effective pharmaceutical treatments for AIDS, I had the pleasure to meet the brilliant doctor who was the head of the NIH Institute for Infectious Disease, Anthony Fauci during grand rounds at the University of Colorado. He spoke of complementary therapy, and encouraged by this, I asked him what Western Medicine could offer in the way of balancing and harmonizing the immune system (something Chinese medicine is reputed to do). In a very affronted tone, he replied, "Western medicine?!?!? You mean the way WE practice medicine?!?!?!?"

That night, I put words on what I wished I had been able to say to him. On that day in the 1980s, I wish I had said, "Maybe you have the luxury of practicing only one kind of medicine, but I have AIDS and at this point in time your medicine has nothing that can help me. I don't have the same luxury you do."

Twenty-five years later, through a combination of the best that Western and Complementary medicine can offer, faith healing, spiritual practice, diet, exercise, counseling and a whole lot more, I am still here and remarkably healthy. I have seen things that defy explanation. I believe I have watched people die because they refused pharmaceutical treatment that I think would have saved them, and I believe I have watched people die because they refused alternative practices that I think would have saved them.

Both Dr. Fauci and Dr. Sha have had their roles to play in my own healing journey. I am grateful to them both.

Thank you, Sara, for introducing a very interesting conversation.

Charles Horowitz, Ph.D. said...

Shunya's comment points to a poignant, general observation: for us Westerners, if it can't be explained, it's not real!
The other side of which is that it's easy to fall for superstitions.

wordwarrior said...

In life, one will get out of it what one puts into it. For the skeptics, I guess they would rather die with their belief systems intact.

I can relate a personal story when in 2005 because of a 6 months lull in my Taichi practice prior to going to China to marry my fiancee, I developed a frozen and very painful shoulder, which my western trained doctor diagnosed as an old person's disease ( I was 66 at the time )and that is something I had to wear as there is no cure.

In China, I went to a sports institute recommended to me and had a course of acupuncture treatment for 3 months and my shoulder become loose and pliant and I can move and put on a shirt without any problem though some pain persisted. I had several large syringe full of yellow fluid injected into my arm and notice some further improvements though not fully cured.

After two very painful manipulation of my arm I was fully cured of my problematic shoulder and was taught some very simple exercises (Climbing the wall)and today, I continue having a pain free shoulder.

Sure, the treatment cost money but was miniscule compared to what I paid at home.

Had I not taken a chance on alternative TCM (Traditional Chinese Medicine) I would have been a degenerating cripple now.

For the skeptics, take it how you will because, you will have to live with your decisions and state of health.

janatd33 said...

There are naysayers--closed minded skeptics--and there are open minded skeptics. In India there is a saying, "test your water and test your guru." There are those who would not test, period. All approaches have their rewards and consequences, no?
Ever since Ed McMahon's Publisher ClearingHouse Sweepstakes guaranteed that I was a finalist to possibly win a million bucks every day for the rest of my life, I've been an advocate for the open minded skeptic position as the most skillful. But I, too, tried acupuncture and found it to help certain conditions-- and not others, which coincidentally is what the recent Time magazine with the cover story on chronic pain said that research shows to be so. May we all find what works! Charles

Anonymous said...

This is so much bullshit I cannot believe that anybody who has a mind of their own would fall for such goob. If you want to take part in such foolery just watch TV and you will find a flock of so called healers all pretending to have some divine power bestowed upon them by some higher power or some secrets that are only available to them.

Anonymous said...

A PSA of 266 is a number that never been seen in the annuals of medicine. The highest documented PSA level was in the high 30s.

What is PSA? It is Prostate Specific Antigen. If you have a prostate gland it is always producing PSA. When the prostate is removed the PSA level drops to zero. The amount of PSA is directly proportional to the size of the prostate gland. The bigger the gland the more PSA it puts out, simply as that. It is no way causes cancer, nor does it feed the cancer, is a marker that is used to determine the size of the prostate. The trick is to figure out why it is enlarged, cancer is certainly one of these causes but in no way is the only possible choice. Most enlarged prostates are classified as BPH, Benign Prostatic Hyperplasia, a medical term for enlarged prostate. Normal PSA is 0-4, but a number lower than 4 does not preclude the absence of cancer. PSA has to be used along with other methods of testing mainly digital exams then ultra-sound and finally biopsy. The digital exam is an extremely good method to determine if the next steps are necessary. Besides using the PSA test to determine the size of the prostate the doctor is able to determine other factors such as firmness, surface irregularities, both sides of the prostate are equal in size etc. etc.

Anonymous said...

I have been tracking an elevated PSA level since 1997 when my annual physical with my family doctor included a PSA test. It was 8.8, normal range is 0-4, obviously I was twice the highest normal number. I was then referred to a urologist who I have been going to every 3-4-6 months since 1997. My PSA has ranged from the 8.8 to a high of 14.7 and many points between those numbers. During each visit besides the PSA blood test I have had at least a digital exam, sometimes ultra sound, and three biopsies. The first two of these biopsies came back clear. The last one in December 2010 came back with five out of the twelve samples taken had cancerous cells. I then had a nuclear medicine bone scan and a soft tissue MRI to see if the cancer was contained in the prostate or had spread. Fortunately both scans were clear, meaning that the cancer was encapsulated in the prostate. At that point I was given options by my urologist. I could do nothing right away but keep tracking it and see how it progresses. Prostate cancer is an extremely slow growing form of cancer,if discovered early enough, as mine was there is no need to rush into any decision about treatment. The second option was to have radiation treatment. After talking to the radiologist and learning of the side effects, length of treatment, etc etc. I decided not to have radiation. I then talked to the surgeon in the group who is trained in robotic surgery. I decided that surgery was best for me. The side effects are minimal, if at all. The operation is only a few hours long. There is no loss of blood. You are sent home the next day. Normal recoup time is two weeks. I have about a four inch incision which they don't even staple or stitch, they glue it together with DermaBond, which dissolves in a few weeks. The best part though is that the cancerous organ is no longer in your body which it would have been if I had chosen radiation treatment.

I highly recommend that men over 50 have a PSA test done on annual basis and if elevated find a good urologist like I did.

Subscribe to future blog posts

Enter your email address: